Week in Space Data, every Friday.
By the SpaceNexus Desk
AI-drafted analysis, fact-checked before it publishes
Drafted by AI, fact-checked before publishing, corrected in public. How the desk works
SpacePolicyOnline reported that in January, NASA will begin assessing new strategies to return the samples now being collected by the Mars Perseverance rover to Earth. The agency had ended its earlier Mars Sample Return (MSR) program, so the samples collected in Jezero Crater remain on Mars with no approved return path. The January assessment is a study step, not a program start. No architecture, cost, schedule or partner has been announced in the sources reviewed.
The same week, the Senate Appropriations Committee released five more FY2027 bills, including the Commerce-Justice-Science bill. The CJS subcommittee is proposing $24.874 billion for NASA, described in the excerpt as slightly more than a comparison figure that the source text cuts off. We therefore do not state the size of the increase or the baseline. Appropriations bills are proposals, and final funding will depend on negotiations with the House and the White House, in a Congress that is about to change political control, as covered earlier.
Perseverance has been caching rock and regolith samples chosen for scientific value, including for the search for signs of past life. Their value depends on getting them to laboratories on Earth, where instruments far more capable than anything flown to Mars can analyze them. Without a return mission, the collection effort is stranded science. The January assessment signals that NASA has not abandoned the goal, but also that it has not committed to a method.
The earlier MSR architecture was a multi-element, multi-launch effort involving a lander, a retrieval vehicle, an ascent vehicle and an orbiter, and it faced cost and schedule growth that led to its cancellation. Public reporting on the cancellation is outside the provided sources, so the details here are limited. What matters for this briefing is that the new assessment is explicitly about new strategies, which suggests lower-cost or different architectures will be considered, including commercial and international options. The sources do not name any.
Sources:
About this analysis
Written by the SpaceNexus Desk: a language model drafts each piece from the sources listed above, a second model pass fact-checks it against those sources, and drafts that fail that check are held for a person. No human typed this article. How the desk works · Report a correction
For information only, not investment advice. SpaceNexus is not a registered investment adviser, broker or dealer, and nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security. Data may be delayed, estimated or incomplete; check the source before acting. Full disclaimer
China has declared ambitions for its own Mars sample return mission, and it recently put a date on a crewed lunar landing (covered earlier). Whether a Chinese mission returns Mars samples first is a recurring point in policy discussion, though the sources provided do not give a schedule. For the US, the question is whether to treat Mars sample return as a flagship scientific priority, an exploration stepping stone, or a program to defer while the Moon base effort (covered earlier with the PROMISE rover awards) takes priority.
One free email on Fridays: launches flown, funding rounds, hiring and schedule slips from our own trackers, plus next week's launches. One click to leave.
Any new strategy will likely lean on commercial capability. Heavy-lift launch, in-space transfer, entry-descent-landing technology and ascent systems are all areas where companies could compete. SpaceX has publicly discussed Starship's potential for Mars missions, and the successful orbital catch of Ship 42 on November 14 (covered earlier) is relevant background to that argument, though it is not evidence that a Mars sample mission is planned. With Vulcan grounded after its November 15 failure, the number of US vehicles available for large science missions is smaller in the near term, though a sample return mission would not launch for years.
Planetary scientists have placed Mars sample return at the top of decadal priorities in the past. A restart gives them something to advocate for, while a prolonged absence of a plan raises concerns about the age of the cached samples and the rover's own lifetime, since Perseverance's ability to deliver samples to a lander depends on its health.
The $24.874 billion Senate figure is the frame in which any new mission would compete. NASA's priorities include the ISS transition (see the authorization bill proposing operations to 2032), Artemis, science, and technology development. A Mars sample return mission needs sustained multi-year funding, and the appropriations language could include direction on the study, which we cannot confirm from the excerpts.
ESA was a partner in the earlier architecture. Any new strategy will need to address what role Europe plays, and how hardware already in development is used or repurposed. The sources do not indicate partner discussions.
Expect NASA to solicit input, possibly from industry and academia, and to produce options with costs and schedules. The outputs of the assessment will show whether the agency favors a smaller, simpler mission, a commercially procured service, or a deferred decision. Any preferred path would then need to appear in a budget request, which means a decision cycle that extends into FY2028 at the earliest unless Congress acts sooner.
The incoming Democratic-controlled committees (earlier coverage) may view science priorities differently from the current leadership, and may press NASA on the status of samples. Watch whether the final CJS bill includes language or funding for a new Mars sample return concept.
The main risks are time and cost. The longer the delay, the more the rover ages and the more competing missions take funding. A new strategy that repeats the cost growth of the earlier one would face the same fate. Conversely, a lean commercial approach carries technical risk because no one has yet launched from the surface of Mars.
The next launch anywhere.
Next launch anywhere
GOWed, Nov 18, 22:50 UTC · Taiyuan Satellite Launch Center
Thu, Nov 19, 6:50 AM GMT+8 at the pad
Launches in 2 days 13 hours
Read next · Lunar Week
The Lunar Week: Griffin listed for January 6, a US funding deadline, ispace agreements →